NFL fans are buzzing with a debate that’s heating up faster than a tailgate in Texas: the 2025 ESPN survey of NFL coaches, scouts, and executives ranking the top 10 quarterbacks. Kickstarted by comedian and sports enthusiast Brandon Perna (@BrandonPerna) on X, the list has sparked a wildfire of opinions, with Patrick Mahomes holding the #1 spot and a surprising rookie, Jayden Daniels, landing at #5 after just one season. But is this a bold salute to a new generation of QB talent, or a hasty coronation that snubs veterans and overlooked stars like C.J. Stroud? Let’s dive into the stats, the stories, and the chatter to break down this controversial ranking.
The List That Lit the Fuse
On July 14, 2025, Perna shared the ESPN-compiled list, based on votes from NFL insiders, which shakes out like this:
- Patrick Mahomes
- Josh Allen
- Joe Burrow
- Lamar Jackson
- Jayden Daniels
- Matthew Stafford
- Justin Herbert
- Jared Goff
- Jalen Hurts
- Baker Mayfield
The top four—Mahomes, Allen, Burrow, and Jackson—feel like a no-brainer, a lineup of Super Bowl winners, MVPs, and statistical juggernauts. But Jayden Daniels at #5, straight out of his rookie year with the Washington Commanders, has thrown a wrench into the works. Meanwhile, the absence of C.J. Stroud and the lower slots for proven guns like Herbert have fans and analysts firing off hot takes. Let’s dig in.
Jayden Daniels: Rookie Firecracker or Overhyped Flash?
Daniels’ jump to #5 is fueled by a jaw-dropping 2024 season. The LSU standout, snagged second overall in the 2024 NFL Draft, rewrote the rookie QB record book with 1,343 rushing yards—an NFL mark that tops Michael Vick’s old standard. Add in 3,589 passing yards and 22 touchdowns, and you’ve got a recipe for an NFC Championship run with the Commanders. That performance nabbed him the 2024 Offensive Rookie of the Year and drew parallels to Lamar Jackson, another dual-threat QB who flipped the game upside down.
But vaulting a rookie to #5? That’s where the rubber meets the road. Daniels’ 2024 breakout rode a retooled Commanders offense and a soft schedule, with Pro Football Focus noting his adjusted completion percentage (78.3%) as top-tier but leaning heavily on short throws (62% under 10 yards). Compare that to Justin Herbert at #7, who’s racked up over 4,000 passing yards in four of his five seasons, including 3,899 yards and 27 TDs in 2023 despite nagging injuries. Herbert’s career passer rating (94.7) smokes Daniels’ rookie 91.2, yet the survey bets on upside over track record.
X users are all over this. @amilian called Daniels’ #5 spot “laughable” after one year, while @RollCoveragePod jabbed at Baker Mayfield’s playoff win, hinting at recency bias. Sports analytics, often dissected in journals like the Journal of Quantitative Analysis in Sports, favor career consistency—Herbert’s 0.89 touchdown-to-interception ratio over five years trumps Daniels’ 1.22 in a single season. Is this a seismic shift in how we rate QBs, or a rush to anoint the next big thing?
The Snubbed Star: C.J. Stroud’s No-Show
Then there’s the elephant in the room: Houston Texans’ C.J. Stroud, nowhere to be found in the top 10. Stroud’s 2023 rookie year was a masterclass—leading the NFL in passing yards per game (273.9) and touchdown-to-interception ratio (4.61), a stat line matched only by legends like Joe Montana (1989) and Tom Brady (2007). His 4,108 yards and 23 TDs powered the Texans to a playoff win and an AFC South crown, yet he’s off the list while Baker Mayfield, with a career 62.7% completion rate and no playoff wins before 2024, clings to #10.
This gap smells like bias. NFL voting trends, per BetCarolina.com, show 84% of MVP awards since 2000 going to QBs, with 70% from playoff teams. Stroud’s Texans stumbled in 2024 (10-7, early playoff exit per Yahoo Sports), possibly dimming his shine. Meanwhile, Mayfield’s Tampa Bay Buccaneers snagged a playoff win in 2024, giving him a boost. @ugandasjoy01 on X demanded, “How is Stroud not there?”—a cry that suggests team success might outweigh individual stats in these polls.
Old Guard vs. New Blood: A Generational Showdown
The list also pits grizzled vets against rising stars. Matthew Stafford (#6) and Jared Goff (#8), both Super Bowl champs, sit below Daniels despite a combined 67,000+ passing yards and 400+ TDs. Jalen Hurts (#9), fresh off a Super Bowl win in 2024, feels undervalued with his 2023 dual-threat numbers (3,858 passing yards, 15 rushing TDs). @saintZda pitched a rework—Allen at #1, Lamar at #2, Hurts at #5, and Daniels out—a take resonating with fans who see the rookie’s rank as premature.
Herbert’s #7 slot, despite his cannon arm and 6’6” frame, has drawn flak. @jbeezley107 joked that Herbert gets “an unlimited leash because of his height,” nodding to his physical tools overshadowing a 0-3 playoff record. Yet his 2024 stats (4,120 yards, 28 TDs) outpace Daniels’, hinting the survey might lean on storylines over spreadsheets—a point ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler flagged as a pitfall of subjective rankings.
The Bigger Picture: Bias in the Booth?
This ranking mirrors broader NFL quirks. Lamar Jackson, a two-time MVP with three First-Team All-Pro nods, lands at #4, which ftw.usatoday.com dubbed “underrated” given his dual-threat reign. The survey’s reliance on coaches, scouts, and execs—many with team loyalties—could tilt results toward hype trains or recent playoff darlings. Daniels’ buzz, built on his Heisman-winning college run and 2024 fireworks, might be inflating his stock, while Stroud’s quieter 2024 could have cost him.
The timing—mid-July, pre-training camp—adds fuel. As @FathedRocks and @ScooterMagruder dropped image-only posts, X’s sports threads lean on memes (60% of discussions use visuals, per 2024 social media data) to vent skepticism. With the 2025 season on the horizon, this list is a snapshot, not a crystal ball—yet it’s already shaping betting lines and fan chatter.
Conclusion: A Ranking in Flux
Jayden Daniels at #5 is a shoutout to his rookie brilliance and a potential overreach. The list’s stumbles—downplaying Herbert and Stroud, overhyping recency—reveal the messy art of ranking in a stats-driven age. As training camps kick off and the 2025 season unfolds, Daniels’ play will either back this ranking or bust it wide open. For now, the Xverse, with voices like @MadCowReturns musing on Bo Nix and @grounded_falcon eyeing reshuffles, keeps the debate alive. One truth stands: in the NFL’s QB circus, the only sure bet is change—and this 2025 list is just the opening kickoff.
What’s your call? Is Daniels’ ranking a game-changer or a misfire? Hit the comments and let’s hash it out!
Read more Articles :